Author Options:

I tried the cookie recipe. What the heck happened? Answered

I followed this recipe very closely and my oven was preheated. The cookies were the flattest cookies you could imagine and wet and oily.



Best Answer 6 months ago

Hmm...I'm sorry to hear this happened. If the cookies were wet, oily, and flat, there was simply too much fat in your batter. I would recommend that you double check your recipe and try again. Much of baking is about trial and error before you get a recipe perfect. Let me know if you have any other questions and good luck!