3829Views56Replies

Author Options:

Is it illegal to share broadband internet in the US? Answered

I was wondering if it was illegal to share broadband internet with your neighbors? This could be wired or wireless. With neighbors you know or dont know.

Please, if you can, site some legal documents.

Thank you,
danfolkes

Discussions

0
None
Ds HaKa

6 years ago

I know I'm breaking the rule of forums but you are stealing bandwidth. Also let's say they have a data cap. You are stealing some of the potential browsing they paid for. Either way, I really don't care. The signal's unlocked, so I'm going to use it.

0
None
YerboogiemanKiteman

Reply 10 years ago

not if its free, if its free they are just giving it away, as in you can have it kind of like starbucks, they give free WiFi

0
None
GoodhartYerboogieman

Reply 10 years ago

Following what Kiteman said then, if it is free, you have "permission" to use it. :-)

0
None
KitemanGoodhart

Reply 10 years ago

Yes, if it's a public "wifi hotspot", then they are there to be used by anybody that can.

If, however, you are able to pick up a private individual's wifi, and they have neglected to switch on the "key", you are committing an offence (in the UK) if you use it without their permission (see my link, posted June 8th above)

0
None
YerboogiemanKiteman

Reply 10 years ago

in the US if they didnt put a password then its not an offence

0
None
jtobakoYerboogieman

Reply 10 years ago

That's like saying "He didn't lock the front door, so it's not burglary."

0
None
NachoMahmajtobako

Reply 10 years ago

. If the SSID is being broadcast and WEP/WPA/whatever is not turned on, then, in my book, that is an open invitation. More like opening the front door and posting a sign saying "Free pizza inside. Come on in." My front door doesn't radiate into the neighbors' yards and houses. . I use my neighbor's WiFi when testing laptops, &c. I tried to get him to let me turn off SSID broadcast and turn on security, but he didn't want to - go figure. While I have his permission to use his WiFi for testing, it is technically a violation of the contract with his ISP.

0
None
jtobakoNachoMahma

Reply 10 years ago

So if the front door is unlocked and you are putting dinner on, anyone who walks/drives by can stop in for free food? Your neighbor probably doesn't want to deal with the security on his computer.

0
None
NachoMahmajtobako

Reply 10 years ago

. If I put a welcome sign up (broadcast my SSID), they can. . I'm not saying it's a good thing to use someone else's WiFi without permission, just that if one is going to bombard me with radio waves, I have a right to use those waves as I see fit. If you don't want me using your WiFi, it's up to you to block me. At the very least, don't advertise the fact that you are there and NEVER turn off password/encryption. Even a noobie can handle those tasks. An intermediate user can setup MAC filtering without problems. &c, &c, &c. . > Your neighbor probably doesn't want to deal with the security on his computer. . I think it's more that, in spite of me trying to explain it to him, he just doesn't understand: 1) he's leaving his network wide open and 2) fixing the problem would be transparent to him.

0
None
jtobakoNachoMahma

Reply 10 years ago

I wish. If you use broadcast cable without paying for it, you get in trouble. If you listen in on someone's cell phone call, you get in trouble. Just because the the radio waves impinge upon you doesn't make them yours. Doesn't make a lot of sense, but that's how the rules were set up. A lot of people chose to be blind. Or, I should say, everyone choses to be blind about some things. You pick and chose what to worry about or you never get a chance to relax.

0
None
NachoMahmajtobako

Reply 10 years ago

. The Law be damned! If you don't want me using your radio waves, then keep them off my property. If you purposely throw something in my backyard, it's mine. ;) . If you don't want me to see you nekkid, then don't stand in front of an open window. If you don't want me using your waves, then don't beam them at me. . As I said before, I don't think it's a good thing to use others' WiFi w/o permission. But I also think they should take a certain amount of responsibility to secure their connections if they want to keep things private - I have locks on my doors and curtains on the windows. When I had a wireless router running, I had SSID turned off, WPA turned on, and MAC filtering enabled - not bullet-proof, but it blocked several hack attempts. . Same for cell phones - you should expect someone to be listening in with their scanner (although from what I've heard you can't do that with the newer phones). Might not be legal, but I've seen it happen.

0
None
YerboogiemanNachoMahma

Reply 10 years ago

Exactly! if they didnt want me using their radiowaves or wireless internet KEEP IT OFF MY PROPERTY, thank you very much....

0
None
jtobakoYerboogieman

Reply 10 years ago

Let's put it in a slightly different context. If I take your photo in a public place or from my property, can I use it in any way I want? Even if you would consider it slander (after all, you let the light waves reflect off you and onto my property)? (Think Photoshop and advertising.)

0
None
NachoMahmajtobako

Reply 10 years ago

. Last time I checked (25-30 years ago, so it may well be out-of-date), one gives up most rights to privacy when one is in a public place, so, yes, you can take my picture in the park and use it w/o my permission. Judging by what I've seen of the paparazzi, it's still OK. If you alter the pic and publish it, you may be open to a slander/defamation/&c civil suit. . Not sure about when I'm on my property, but I'll stand by my "keep it off of my property if you don't want me looking" policy. That's what fences are for. ;)

0
None
jtobakoNachoMahma

Reply 10 years ago

The point is that you have let your light waves onto my property, and now I can do whatever I want to them, right? How is this different than your use of any radio signal that enters your property? I'm just checking to see what would happen when the tables are turned (after all, YOUR wifi signal has to go onto someone-else's property to request a response...).

0
None
NachoMahmajtobako

Reply 10 years ago

> The point is that you have let your light waves onto my property, and now I can do whatever I want to them, right? . Yes. If I don't want you using my photons, I need to keep them on my property and away from you. That's why I have curtains on my windows. . > I'm just checking to see what would happen when the tables are turned . I made an attempt to make my router private. Someone would have had to go to some trouble to hack my signal. Maybe not a lot of trouble, but they couldn't just auto-connect. I didn't leave the door open and post a "Y'all come on in" sign. . I suppose what I'm trying to say is that leaving your WiFi connection open is tantamount to contributory negligence. No, it's not "right" for someone to piggyback, but if you leave your connection wide open, you get what you deserve. Kinda like leaving your keys in your your new 's ignition with the windows rolled down and expecting it to be there when you return. I can't condone someone stealing that car, but don't expect any sympathy from me, either.

0
None
YerboogiemanNachoMahma

Reply 10 years ago

you seem to be doing a good job although, this cant go on forever, lets just let it go, and quit talking, its not going anywhere anyway

0
None
GoodhartNachoMahma

Reply 10 years ago

Some insurance companies will NOT pay for vandalized cars in repair garages or car lots IF the cars are LOCKED. go figure, eh ?

0
None
Yerboogiemanjtobako

Reply 10 years ago

heh. try to get my password, that'd be funny just to see you try

0
None
jtobakoNachoMahma

Reply 10 years ago

Personally, I agree completely. But I know that the law doesn't work that way and would rather give a warning than condolences : (

0
None
NachoMahmajtobako

Reply 10 years ago

. Yeah. But I feel better, now that I got that off my chest. heehee

0
None
killerjackalopejtobako

Reply 10 years ago

It is? I'm a monster, god I always thought it was like a yard sale for free...

0
None
Yerboogiemanjtobako

Reply 10 years ago

thats different, thats theft, this is WIRELESS, not wired, or stealing, they didnt put a password, they didnt care, its free to use, like starbucks

0
None
GoodhartYerboogieman

Reply 10 years ago

From the article I link to below comes this: The recent arrest of a Florida man on charges of unauthorized use of a wireless network could set legal ground rules for open Wi-Fi access. A man sitting in a Chevy Blazer in a residential neighborhood reportedly was poking around nearby wireless networks in violation of computer crime laws, according to local police. This appears to be the first arrest in which the sole offense was allegedly accessing a wireless network without prior authorization, and it's already being viewed as a probable test case. CNET News.com interviewed legal scholars to ask what rules apply to Wi-Fi (also called 802.1x) hot spots.

0
None
Pumpkin$Goodhart

Reply 10 years ago

how do they get caught does someone have premonitions and check wireless connections?

0
None
GoodhartPumpkin$

Reply 10 years ago

It is possible that they were "caught in the act" while they suspiciously sat outside the residence in a car with a laptop? *shrug*

0
None
jtobakoGoodhart

Reply 10 years ago

I believe he was there for several days in a row.

0
None
Goodhartjtobako

Reply 10 years ago

That would make sense, too.

0
None
jtobakoYerboogieman

Reply 10 years ago

A wireless network is still a network. This isn't about ethics, it's about the letter of a law that was written by either someone who didn't have the technical background (legislator) or by someone who did (lobbyist/corporation) looking out for their own best interest (pay for your own connection, not use someone else's). If you aren't using your lawn at the time, and don't put up a fence, can I park my car their-since you aren't using it?

0
None
Pumpkin$jtobako

Reply 10 years ago

I withdraw my earlier comment

0
None
GoodhartKiteman

Reply 10 years ago

Yes, understood...by free I meant also one has permission, that is, they are not exclusive. If one hasn't permission, then it is not free, and vise versa. It is considered an offense here too but not necessarily illegal:

CNET article: WiFi mooching and the law

0
None
VIRONKiteman

Reply 11 years ago

In the UK they have that with wireless (aerial/antenna) TV also. Still true?

0
None
Patrik

10 years ago

Interesting choice of words by the original poster.

Of course, you can share broadband internet with your neighbor. Just like you can share your cake with your neighbor.

Mind you, if you were to "share" his cake without his knowledge or permission... well, that's not really called "sharing", is it?

0
None
crosman01

11 years ago

i think it's legal but if you do it 1:nearly nobody knows for sure so if anyone notices they probably won't like call the police. 2:and if they do i think there is like some waver law that if you didn't know you can't be punished.

0
None
NachoMahmacrosman01

Reply 11 years ago

. Re your second point: Ignorantia juris non excusat is the official public policy in the US.

0
None
NachoMahmacrosman01

Reply 11 years ago

. You are indeed!. It's the Language of Law (at least in the US).
. And it should have been italicized, not bolded - mea culpa (Yikes! More Latin!).

0
None
killerjackalopeNachoMahma

Reply 10 years ago

You studied yourself? I remember very little but the important things like dog stuck..

0
None
killerjackalopeNachoMahma

Reply 10 years ago

Ah right, I was forced to do it for three years in school, so I resort to talking dirty to my teacher, in latin, which is suprisingly difficult.

0
None
killerjackalopejtobako

Reply 10 years ago

I went, apparently italians understood my filth perfectly well despite the language barrier, and because I was mistaken for italian most of the time (by italians) I started getting the gist of most things they say, I also learnt some rather choice german phrases from two german girls on the trip, including take off your clothes, bitch but that's another story, overall my latin was useless except in the remains of some different places we saw, I translated for our translator to translate in to italian, english, dutch and german all while another translator covered french, portuguese and some other language...

0
None
westfw

11 years ago

It is probably against the service agreement you have with your internet service provider. Ie, it's essentially a contract violation rather than an explicit law.

0
None
NachoMahmawestfw

Reply 11 years ago

. I think it would probably be considered theft of services, in addition to breach of contract. Since it involves interstate commerce, that might kick it up to Federal Court. . If anyone knows for sure, please speak up.

0
None
jtobakoNachoMahma

Reply 10 years ago

It's illegal access to a computer network, basically falling under hacking laws.

0
None
jtobakojtobako

Reply 10 years ago

Sorry, forgot the "without permission" part : (

0
None
westfwjtobako

Reply 10 years ago

Well, that's the question, isn't it. Who gets to give "permission"? If I tell my neighbor "sure, you can use my wireless router to connect to the internet via my comcast connection" then they have permission, right?