108Views17Replies

Author Options:

Rating System Answered

Never mind---just read this if you're bored or something......Canida explained it for me
What happened Instructables?! All of a sudden half of the instuctables on this site are boosted up a whole number! My best instructable used to be 4.08 which was very good but now all of a sudden its 5 exactly. I feel the new rating system is too easy and it is making it so every instructable has ratings which are way too high. I cant even sort by rating anymore because there's at least 1,000 instructables that are 5 stars and it doesnt show me the true best instructable of that category! Please fix!

Discussions

0
None
H1T4TCH1

8 years ago

I second.

0
None
BrittLivH1T4TCH1

Reply 8 years ago

Have you read this article? https://www.instructables.com/community/Pro-Membership-details-more-visible-ratings-calcu/


"Ratings are higher. Based on comparisons throughout the entire Internet (well, OK, only a small part of it, but we tried to take a diverse sample) we realized that Instructables' star values were lower by comparison than most other places, for content that's comparable or better. So we are bumping them up a star. Yeah it's ratings inflation, so sue us. Your Instructables are as good as anything else on the web, and often far better, and we want to make sure the world in general sees that. The actual update is going to happen in stages over the next few days as there are a lot of ratings to change and we want to avoid the possibility of a site slowdown from so much database work all at once. Anything you rate from now on, though, will show the new values immediately."

0
None
kelseymhH1T4TCH1

Reply 8 years ago

You did, but I'm willing to be the original poster (running a week or two behind the rest of us) didn't bother.

0
None
ElectroinnovationH1T4TCH1

Reply 8 years ago

Hes talking about me and yes i read that but it is stupid and a pointless reason and I personally liked it a lot better where the best instructable on the site was only about 4.8 and everything went down from there. It makes it a lot more accurate as opposed to having so many 5* rated instructables. And im not just jelous because I now have a 5* instructable but it's not right.

0
None
caitlinsdadElectroinnovation

Reply 8 years ago

It's like Instructables Robot subscribed to all the K'nex'ers and rated their ibles a 6.0 because it can. That's about accurate.

0
None
Electroinnovationcaitlinsdad

Reply 8 years ago

not just knex, all instructables. And it just boosted them all a point for a barely adequate reason.

0
None
canidaElectroinnovation

Reply 8 years ago

I hear you. Here's something the update didn't mention:

We've experimented with lots of different rating algorithms, and quite frankly none of them have been very good. The most recent version kept everything hovering around a 3 for way too long, even if everyone gave it a 5 - not in line with what the raters intended. It has previously been impossible to reach 5, even if everyone rates it a 5 - and that's just not right. Our algorithm was just not very good.

The big reason we swapped the ratings to match with other sites: they'll be appearing in Google search. Most people who search have never been to Instructables before, and they're scrolling along a page with other sites that also have ratings. Knowing nothing else, would you click on something that had a 3.5 rating, or a 5 rating? We're changing things up to make sure your projects get the attention they deserve.

0
None
kelseymhcanida

Reply 8 years ago

This is great information, Canida! Would you be willing to add this (either in the topic itself, or as a sticky comment) to the main FAQ about the rating system? It'd be nice to get that updated with a description of the new algorithm, too :-)

0
None
LoneWolf

8 years ago

Why on earth are you upset because your instructables have magnificent ratings now?

0
None
kelseymhLoneWolf

Reply 8 years ago

When everybody's special, nobody's special.

0
None
Tool Using AnimalLoneWolf

Reply 8 years ago

Because a meaningless gold star, to some people is still a gold star, to others, it's meaningless.