Running DC motor underwater? Answered

10050Views9Replies

Author Options:

I have heard that DC motors can run underwater and am trying to build a project with them running underwater. I recently tried running a brush less DC cooling fan underwater and it broke. Meanwhile I tried another mini DC motor, the kind that cost $.99 each and it worked fine. Does anyone have any ideas why one worked and the other did not? Does it have to do with being brushed or not? Lastly would something like http://www.pololu.com/catalog/product/1117 theoretically run underwater? Thanks.

Discussions

0
None
steveastrouk

Best Answer 6 years ago

Brushed will work for a bit, brushless should work for ever, bearings permitted.

0
None
Hammock Boysteveastrouk

Answer 6 years ago

Is a "bit" once or twice in the water or should I get most of their life out of them?

0
None
steveastroukHammock Boy

Answer 6 years ago

Once or twice in my experience. Brushless is the way to go.

0
None
steveastroukHammock Boy

Answer 6 years ago

WAY too much torque load ! You'd've run the thing wildly over current.

0
None
Hammock Boysteveastrouk

Answer 6 years ago

would submerging it into a glass of water do that? it was only meant to move air.

0
None
TonyK33

2 years ago

Old but. The reason those oil pc's fans don't have issues is exactly that. The oil is non-conductive and the brushes don't arc and gap instantly.

0
None
frollard

6 years ago

Somewhat related, I've seen under-oil PCs running with their stock 'air' fans 'blowing' oil over the heatsink in an aquarium filled with mineral oil. The fan shouldn't fail for torque - it runs much much slower but still works...surely to the detriment of the coils if it runs near stall current all the time.

As steve says; brushless never has electricity jumping any gaps, so the only point of failure was if the water wasn't totally pure it may have shorted out the control circuitry driving the brushless-ness.