2169Views16Replies

Author Options:

biology maximum cell size Answered

what stops a cell from being extremly large?

inparticular in prokaryotic cells, like algae, where it is the cell and is not part of something bigger like a tissue or organ.

also in the way of darwins theroy of evolution, does any one know how much it appiles to algae, either all or some strains and how much they addapt and how quickly?

Discussions

0
None
rickharris

7 years ago

Well technically noting - For example an ostrich egg is a VERY LARGE single cell. However If your asking why single cell animals don't grow big I suspect it is more to do with the food chain.

0
None
juliedoll19

7 years ago

The reason cells don't get extremely large is because they are limited by the surface area to volume ratio. Cells expel waste and bring nutrients in through diffusion. Everything is trafficked through the cell membrane. If the cell is too large, the movement of materials to and from the center is too far from the surface to move effectively.

0
None
kelseymhjuliedoll19

Reply 7 years ago

That's generally the correct argument, but there are exceptions :-)

https://www.instructables.com/community/How-big-can-a-cell-be/

0
None
thelastonekillsjuliedoll19

Reply 7 years ago

i get that bit, but why does the cell try and have the lowerst surface area possible?
and could anything be done to change why it does this?

0
None
kelseymhthelastonekills

Reply 7 years ago

You have it backwards. The cell needs the maximum surface area possible, because of exactly what Juliedoll19 wrote.

0
None
Jugglebug

8 years ago

well, for one thing there are some extremely large (eukaryotic, admittedly) cells in nature- eggs are single cells, including ostrich eggs :D

But I believe the reason other cells are small is the danger of lysis- bursting and spillage of the cytoplasm (who broke those eggs....)- it is potentially unsafe to have larger cells with comparatively thin cell membranes.

Cell membranes usually consist of just a thin layer of protein, carbohydrate etc. The reason for this is to allow for selective permeability- much more difficult on a larger scale.

The size of cells is therefore limited by the practicality of a thick cell membrane needed to make them relatively safe from being burst.

Although now that I think about it, the danger may be offset by the potentially quite thick porous cell walls of most algal cells - no idea how effectively these protect from accidental cell lysis

Just some theories, please someone tell me if my biology is way off :-)

0
None
kelseymh

8 years ago

https://www.instructables.com/community/How-big-can-a-cell-be/

Natural selection applies equally to all living things. It just depends on what environmental pressures there are.

0
None
caitlinsdad

8 years ago

Probably something in the DNA signals it to stop or gets triggered?