188Views24Replies

Author Options:

nuclear power in developing countries Answered

im thinking of doing a project in a honors degree in college (level 8) on"is nuclear power in developing countries feasible"

i was wondering what are your opinions on this and is it worth doing?

Discussions

0
None
rich5007

8 years ago

Thanks for all the advice, i now have a much better idea of what areas i need to cover, at the moment i am current breaking down the chapters
Chapter 1: Introduction
Chapter 2: history of nuclear power
Chapter 3:comparrison to other powers
Chapter 4:location of the plant and overview
Chapter 5:social and political consequences
Chapter 6:international consequences
Chapter 7:conclusion


if anyone feels i have left out anything or you feel i should include something let me know thanks.

0
None
kelseymhrich5007

Reply 8 years ago

In Chapter 3, are you planning to compare with other power generation options, or to discuss the different kinds of nuclear power plants?

0
None
rich5007kelseymh

Reply 8 years ago

in chapter 3 I am going to compare nuclear to energy alternatives like solar, wind etc. (comparison of power produced , cost, land area needed, life expectancy, efficiency etc.)

in chapter 2 i was going to include the different types of nuclear power plants

0
None
lemonierich5007

Reply 8 years ago

nuclear power in developing countries is predominately political, up chapter6 a bit,

L

0
None
kelseymhlemonie

Reply 8 years ago

Hmmmm....I think that's a matter of opinion (I believe the political and technical difficulties are about equal, for example). Which is why I think this fellow could produce a very interesting analysis, if he plays his cards right does his research :-)

0
None
lemoniekelseymh

Reply 8 years ago


Could you give an example of a developing country with a nuclear power program that had a minor political aspect?

L

0
None
kelseymhlemonie

Reply 8 years ago

I didn't say "minor." You suggest that the political issues are more important (predominate) than anything else. I believe the technical problems (construction, fuel transport, qualified/trained local staff) are about equal in importance to the politics.

However, if I wanted to be really snarky, I guess I'd say "France" :-)

0
None
kelseymhlemonie

Reply 8 years ago

:-P Told you I was being snarky. I figured an Anglophone would appreciate it :-)

0
None
lemoniekelseymh

Reply 8 years ago


I did appreciate it thanks.

L

0
None
kelseymhrich5007

Reply 8 years ago

Excellent! Thanks for explaining. This sounds like it could be an excellent review.

0
None
rich5007

8 years ago

actually now that i think of it is there any good online poll sites so i can create one. this way i can get an idea of peoples feelings on nuclear power in a developing country?

0
None
kelseymh

8 years ago

What level is this project? Science fair? Undergrad honors thesis? Masters program? Ph.D. in international studies? White paper from the Hoover Institution?

Without more information, it's really hard to give you a concrete answer.

0
None
rich5007kelseymh

Reply 8 years ago

honors degree in college (level 8) sorry should have mentioned that

0
None
kelseymhrich5007

Reply 8 years ago

Okay; thanks! You can edit your topic text to include that information.

At the undergraduate level, an analysis and summary of the existing literature is generally adequate (you don't need to do primary research yourself!). Below, you'll find a lot of jargon; you should use those as search terms to guide your acquisition of material.

You'll need to look at what technologies are currently either available or in development for nuclear power generation (the recent work on encapsulated "microreactors" is extremely interesting!).

You'll need to research the issue of uranium enrichment and the associated military/political issues of "special nuclear materials" security, diversion, dual-use technology, and non-proliferation.

You will certainly want to include some discussion of oversight, governmental stability, and the broader international consequences of introducing a nuclear power program into a country with an unstable regime.

0
None
killerjackalopekelseymh

Reply 8 years ago

I was going to suggest about microreactors, they seem like a really interesting concept for set and forget power, both in remote places and as a more sustainable source of power, from what I've seen many of the designs user lower grade material.

0
None
kelseymhkillerjackalope

Reply 8 years ago

They do seem like a very intriguing concept. They still have the waste vs. reprocessing dilemma as full-size reactors, but the quantity of material is much smaller.

0
None
caitlinsdadkelseymh

Reply 8 years ago

The answer is "We can put a man on the moon...supposedly..." Does the author want to take a look at the question from a purely scientific and logistical standpoint or the other issues of social-political-economic feasibility. Much debate can stem from a simple question.

0
None
rich5007caitlinsdad

Reply 8 years ago

thanks for the advice and replies so far

i had also thought about how other countries could build the plant in a developing country and transport the power over.

0
None
rich5007caitlinsdad

Reply 8 years ago

good point there are many angles i could look at it

0
None
caitlinsdadrich5007

Reply 8 years ago

depends on if you want to save the world, save the human race, are they deserving, will others get jealous, will there be abuse of power. You've got a lot of people on this site that can offer an opinion once you've narrowed down your question(do you sense the particle-physicist and the bohemian young philosopher above? I'm just the regular guy on the street). Good luck.