151Views24Replies

Author Options:

"D'oh!" or "Oh my God, we're all going to die!" ? Answered

This article from New Scientist raises the question posted in the title. Which response is more appropriate?

Discussions

0
None
skunkbait

10 years ago

When I read the forum title, I thought you were talking about our newly inaugurated president!

0
None
kelseymhskunkbait

Reply 10 years ago

Heh, heh! I'm an unreconstructed liberal, and have nothing but joy for our new leader's ascension :-)Do we really need more Messianic metaphors?

0
None
skunkbaitkelseymh

Reply 10 years ago

Oh, you and your messie metaphors! When he turns my water into a nice Merlot or Pinot, then I'll apologise!

0
None
kelseymhskunkbait

Reply 10 years ago

I'm partial to a Carmeniere with dinner, or an Aleateco afterward....and who needs an apology?

0
None
skunkbaitkelseymh

Reply 10 years ago

Oh, I've said things (not on Instructables) that I should probably apologise for. I have verbally crucified the annoying....I mean, anointed one. But nothing a dry Cabernet couldn't fix!

0
None
westfw

10 years ago

So what exactly is in the jug (and how much)? Surely not elemental plutonium, since that would be a solid an inappropriate for a glass bottle. The closeup of the bottle is only slightly readable, and looks like it says:
  • <illegible>
  • LaF3 WASTES
  • FOR RECOVERY
  • <illegible> 1-15mg
  • ~ 20g.La+3
0
None
kelseymhwestfw

Reply 10 years ago

Apparently lanthanum fluoride was used as a carrier for the plutonium extraction process. That makes sense since all the lanthanides and actinides ("rare earth elements") have a strong mutual affinity.

0
None
LinuxH4x0r

10 years ago

So typical of your people :P

0
None
kelseymhLinuxH4x0r

Reply 10 years ago

Oh, come on, you're not going to bring up Vieques again? I promise, I had nothing to do with that :-)

0
None
LinuxH4x0rkelseymh

Reply 10 years ago

I just meant all scientists in general and all humans

0
None
gmoon

10 years ago

I'm gonna print this up for my Dad, who worked at Oak Ridge during WWII. He was a Chem. Engineer straight out of college, completed basic and was then sent to the "Manhattan Engineer District." I think he'll get a kick out of it... or something.

0
None
kelseymhgmoon

Reply 10 years ago

Wow, that is seriously cool. If he was a ChemE at ORNL, I wonder if he worked on the design or implementation of the GC cascades (no, don't ask, he still can't talk about it).

0
None
gmoonkelseymh

Reply 10 years ago

Hypothetically, if he had mentioned anything (I'm not saying he did ;-) ), it would have involved the gaseous diffusion process and uranium isotopes... that's all I'll say. Not a big secret anymore...

His boss asked him once if he knew what was happening (everything being very hush-hush, even in the plant), and he mentioned some theoretical stuff he recalled from college. He was told to keep it to himself.

And safety standards? Nothing like today...

0
None
caitlinsdadgmoon

Reply 10 years ago

And safety standards?
I dunno, but the pic of the dude handling the bottle with just a pair of rubber and leather gloves holding the thing like it belonged to Howard Hughes seemed risky. I would at least expect those lead fire-fighting silver suits and a pooper-scooper pair of tongs, unless it doesn't matter when you get that close...

0
None
kelseymhcaitlinsdad

Reply 10 years ago

Which is a good contrast with what I wrote above. X-rays are highly penetrating (that's why you use them to make shadow images :-), and need much more substantial shielding.

0
None
kelseymhcaitlinsdad

Reply 10 years ago

Plutonium isn't actually that dangerous. It decays by alpha emission and MeV alphas are absorbed by really small thicknesses of material (a sheet of cardboard is good shielding!). In this case, the plutonium solution is in a bottle, so the radiation level from it would be pretty low. The danger of plutonium is getting it inside your system -- breathing dust from machining it, getting a little shard under your skin. In that case, it's in "direct contact" with your cells; alphas are highly disruptive when they hit complex organic molecules (like DNA).

0
None
gmooncaitlinsdad

Reply 10 years ago

Yeah, seriously. I hadn't noticed that picture...

..like it belonged to Howard Hughes..
:D

0
None
Sunbanks

10 years ago

I think that would definitely be "D'oh!"

0
None
Kiteman

10 years ago

More rolls eyes with a gentle sigh.

0
None
Lithium Rain

10 years ago

"Oh my God, we're all going to die!"

O_O Seriously, how can this be?!

0
None
kelseymhLithium Rain

Reply 10 years ago

You mean, how could the people running Hanford have been so cavalier? Sigh...that's is way too long a tale to fit into a forum discussion. Better that you should read some of the DOE, EPA, and independent reports on the issue. It is really appalling.