Homemade Snickers Candy Bar Recipe

PrintPrint PDF FacebookFacebook TwitterTwitter Send this to a friendE-mail
by canida
 

introHomemade Snickers Candy Bar Recipe

Snickers candy bars are awesome, but I wanted to try making them at home without all the stabilizers and additives necessary for a mass-market, shelf-stable candy bar*.  This recipe is super-easy, and makes a full pan of delicious homemade Snickers candy bars!

Beware, they're extremely good, and as I said, the recipe makes LOTS.  Be sure to have a crowd to eat these treats, or the self-control to put them in the freezer for longer-term storage!  My testers report that these candy bars taste even better frozen.

*Yes, I know this version still uses ingredients that contain some stabilizers and additives - they make it taste most like a true Snickers bar.  Feel free to substitute homemade peanut butter, marshmallows, etc to fit your preferences.

Homemade Snickers Candy Bar Recipe
IMG_8213.CR2.jpgIMG_8209.CR2.jpg
 
Remove these adsRemove these ads by Signing Up.
 

step 1Gather materials and ingredients

I'm giving these ingredients by both weight and volume where relevant.  Weighing is much easier, but if you don't have a digital kitchen scale yet* the volume measurements will do. 

Ingredients:

14 oz milk chocolate (about 2 cups chips, or coarsely chopped bar) divided in half
3.5 oz  (1/2 cup) butterscotch chips, divided in half
192 g (3/4 cup) creamy peanut butter, divided into 3 parts (1/4 cup, 64g each)
5.5 tablespoons butter (divided: 4 Tbsp and 1.5 Tbsp)
1 cup sugar
1/2 cup evaporated milk, divided in half
156 g (1.5 cups) marshmallow fluff
1 teaspoon vanilla
1.5 cups salted peanuts, chopped (or substitute nuts of your choice)
1 pound chewy caramels

Optional: (if coating the sides of your bars)
7oz milk chocolate
1.75 oz butterscotch chips
64g creamy peanut butter

Materials:

one 9x13 pan
waxed paper or plastic wrap
microwave-safe bowl
small (1 quart) pot
heat-proof spatula
sharp knife
cutting board
microwave
stove

*No really, you should get a kitchen scale NOW!  They're cheap, and make baking so much easier.  You can get an excellent scale from Amazon for about $25.

Gather materials and ingredients
IMG_7824.JPGIMG_7827.JPGIMG_7828.JPGIMG_8063.JPGIMG_8061.JPG
To Download the PDF or View All Steps,   
Become a Pro Member »
85 comments
1-40 of 85next »
Aug 12, 2010. 12:01 PMsimbry49 says:
I made these and they were great. I only used the microwave for heating things up. I just followed the directions on the bag of choco chips. Do the caramels slowly though, they do not melt very fast. They are ooee gooee
Jun 17, 2010. 8:05 PMkindfirez says:
i made these for the first time about a week ago and due to popular demand i made s econd batch of them tonight, i did have some trouble cutting them into perfect squares but luckily for me noone I know cares. They just say they are better than the real deal. thanks for the recipe it's a keeper
May 25, 2010. 2:50 PMremeriel says:
Wow! I made these for a dessert contest at my church and totally won! I have been asked to bring them to the next event. MAJOR hit! Thanks for such a great recipe!
May 15, 2010. 8:19 AM92033 says:
Sounds super-duper...but 'fattening. Think I'll jest buy the 'Snickers' bars...throw away the bars and eat the wrappers...mmmm...yummy fur yer tummy'. (LOL).

Okay...sounds great...will give it a try. Thanks.

Oh...There's a commercially made frozen Snickers Bar Frozen Pie...anybody have a recipe for it? Super Delicious.
May 4, 2010. 10:07 AMkreisaisjelis says:
 I made this one following the instructions (i believe), but the nougat layer never solidified and remained pretty liquid (honey consistency) even after freezing.

Any ideas why could that be?
Apr 29, 2010. 10:49 AMPeechiz says:
General consensus from our 12th floor office:

OM NOM NOM NOM NOM
Apr 17, 2010. 6:31 AMknexfan100 says:
normal snickers cost $2.50. these homemade bars cst 50 cents per bar to make and taste better and it still satifies
Apr 19, 2010. 7:14 AMKaldric says:
$2.50 for a Snickers bar?  That seems really high.  I can usually find the King Size candy bars for about $1.50 or less where I live, and the regular sizes are often on sale for about $0.50. 

So, if a regular candy bar is approximately 1 inch wide and 4.3 inches long, you could get about 36 regular sized bars in the pan, plus the extra that was cut off to make the nice square edges.  That would cost me about $18 to buy, thus the homemade snickers would be a slightly better price.

I assume, based on the large difference in the cost of the candy bar alone (and the fact that I can get 2 cups of chocolate chips for about $1 as opposed to $5), that I can get the raw ingredients for some price less than what was posted, and would therefore be an even better deal.

Regardless, this looks awesome and I plan to try it out.
May 21, 2010. 8:35 PMknexfan100 says:
In michagan the price shot up by alot the past year. now they finally fixed the price but that does not mean i would buy them because I can make them!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Apr 25, 2010. 9:42 AMChuckVanT says:
 So, what you're saying, Kaldric is it's a single serving?!?  LOL
Apr 19, 2010. 7:37 PMSirisC says:
Don't know where y'all get your snickers, but a regular snickers bar usually costs between $0.20  and $0.50 each at grocery stores (usually 3 per dollar). I might be able to understand $2.50 inside Disney World or at the movie theater.
May 21, 2010. 8:37 PMknexfan100 says:

like i said, the price went back to normal but that does not mean i would buy them because I can make them!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Apr 28, 2010. 10:12 AMmayday295 says:
 Very nicely done!! I cant wait to try this one, and I bet that would have look like a real snickers bar and been thicker had you of put the peanuts on the top layer as you said.

Cant wait!
Apr 27, 2010. 6:22 PMzoneykid says:
I have the exact same bowl as the one in the microwave on step 4! :0
Apr 27, 2010. 10:55 AMtornado96 says:
Is there anything I can replace the butterscotch chips with?
May 9, 2010. 8:06 AMDiana H says:
This is the first time you mention marshmallow fluff?  I assume this is marshmallow creme? You didn't show any pictures of it nor is it in the cost estimate?? Can you clairfy? 
Apr 28, 2010. 12:22 PMnormalfuzz29 says:
I cook for a living and you'd be surprised how much heat plastic wrap can take...I cover foods for the steamer with it and I've found that if you cover items for the oven with it and then a layer of foil it keeps the foil from falling into the food...It sticks to sides of pans but has never melted into anything i have cooked...
May 4, 2010. 3:53 PMSuzanne in Orting says:
I'm still going to chicken out on using plastic wrap because I don't have the nice heavyweight stuff that restaurants use, but you've given me the idea to try a layer of parchment paper under the foil to stop sticking.

The other day, I baked a casserole uncovered until the cheese set then covered it to keep it from drying out.  It worked well.

Suzanne in Orting, WA
Apr 16, 2010. 11:08 PMpie R []ed says:
 I absolutely love Snickers. This is a really cool way to have them homemade! For the dipping, do you think it would be easy to do them on toothpicks, and then even put them on a party plate?
Apr 17, 2010. 8:37 PMlezed1 says:
 it is not step three - where you prepare the pan, but step 4
Apr 19, 2010. 2:40 PMbaldyhugs says:
 sorry for nit picking but wont all the ingredients have additives in them already

i did try it and they did taste very nice
Apr 24, 2010. 3:47 PMjonny_s says:
This is amazing! Thanks so much for posting it! I already had some almonds on hand, and the only caramels I could find were vanilla caramels, so I wound up with vanilla-almond snickers bars. Mmmm....
Apr 15, 2010. 11:00 AMauroraoutdoorlighting says:
 Cooking with plastic wrap? Seems safer to use the wax paper option- wouldn't the plastic be carcinogenic? 
Apr 15, 2010. 7:33 PMauroraoutdoorlighting says:
 Oh, I guess I should have read the remainder of the recipe before I posted! :)
Apr 24, 2010. 1:28 PMjonny_s says:
 Aside from this not actually entering the oven, plastic wrap is also incredibly resilient to heat. Many caterers use plastic wrap to cover their steam trays to either keep food warm or actually steam veggies. I've even seen one caterer use it to cover scalloped potatoes before he put them in the oven. Granted, the wrap is not actually touching the food in this case, but it does show how high of a melting point it has. Warm chocolate is no problem. :)
Apr 17, 2010. 7:58 PMSweetgal says:
 Hey, i feel silly but i'm going to ask anyway...
what is marshmallow fluff
and what can i use as a sub?
Apr 20, 2010. 7:23 AMKaldric says:
Marshmallow Fluff is a product that is apparently commonly available in the Northeast United States.  It has a marshmallow-like flavor with a spreadable consistency.  If you can't find any at your local grocery store, you can probably use an equal quantity (by weight) of marshmallows (melted), or make your own:

http://www.grouprecipes.com/58165/home-made-marshmallow-fluff.html


Apr 19, 2010. 3:22 PMjehan60188 says:
DO WANT!
Apr 17, 2010. 9:03 PMlezed1 says:
 step 4 again
1-40 of 85next »