Introduction: How to Make Awesome Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies

Here's a guide on how to make some yummily chewy cookies. If your cookies keep coming out like hardened disks that work better as frisbees than dessert I have a couple of tips that can help you out regardless of what type of cookie it is.

This recipe is for peanut butter chocolate chip cookies and they are... delicious.

Step 1: Recipe

Dry ingredients:

- 1 cup flour
- 1 tsp baking soda
- 1/4 tsp salt

Stir in small bowl

Wet ingredients:

- 1 cup light brown sugar, packed*
- 1 cup crunchy peanut butter
- 1 stick (1/4 pound or 8 tbsp) unsalted butter, room temperature
- 1 tsp vanilla extract
- 1 large egg
- 1/4 cup honey

Blend in medium bowl

Stir the dry ingredients into the wet ingredients in two additions.

*Yes, brown sugar is technically dry, but since it's mixed with all of the rest of the wet ingredients I just put it there

Step 2: Add Chocolate

I've used chocolate chunks hacked from a huge chocolate bar, broken up smaller chocolate bars, and semi-sweet chocolate chips. All worked out great.

In these photos I'm using 6 oz. semi-sweet chocolate chips. Stir them into the mix.

Cover the bowl and put in the fridge for 30-40 minutes so it's easier to handle.

Step 3: Know Your Oven

Ovens lie. It's a fact of life that some ovens will tell you that they're at the temperature you want and be off by a full 80 degrees. In my previous apartment, the oven was nice and new and had lovely digital controls. It was also a horrible liar hell-bent on ruining my baking attempts.

If I wanted the oven to be at 450, it would let me know it was ready when it was only 370. Five minutes later it would stabilize at 430. That's a full five minutes of your dough being cooked at the wrong temperature, completely throwing you off.

So long story short, buy a thermometer and stick it in the oven. It doesn't have to be pretty, it just has to work so you'll know what the true temperature is.

For this recipe, you'll want it at 350 Fahrenheit or 175 Celsius.

Step 4: Roll Up the Dough

I roll my dough into balls about 1.25" (3cm) wide. You can go a little bigger if you want. I've found that a little bit of variation does not have a noticeable effect on the cooking time. Put them onto a buttered cookie tray.

The trays I use are insulated ones. Getting fancy cookie trays may seem a bit extreme, but there was a period last year where I got a bit obsessed and these have been totally worth it.

So now that you're sure your oven is at 350F/175C and it's stable at that temperature, put the dough in for 12 minutes.

Step 5: Don't Overcook Your Cookies

After 12 minutes the cookies will not look ready, but take them out anyway and put the whole pan out on the counter to cool. Do not touch them!

Oh, you'll want to touch them. You'll want to put one in your mouth right away, your tender tongue be damned, but don't do it. Really.

OK, so you did touch one and it seems fragile and undercooked. That's why you need to let them cool for 5 minutes before moving them to a rack or a plate.

Step 6: Rock Out With Your Cookie

Yay! You waited for the cookies to cool and now they're good to go! You can eat them now or save some for later. These are good on their own or combined with other sugary treats. Like ice cream. Ice cream loves these cookies and vice versa. Let the love flow.

To get the fresh baked warmth and goodness feeling back, quickly zap in a microwave or briefly toss into a toaster.

Eat.

Comments

author
SIRJAMES09 made it! (author)2013-12-16

MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMmmmmmmmmmmmm. 8 D

I printed out this page as well as the other cookie pages....

I'm in Heaven with this recipe! TY for sharing. :)

author
gigi116 made it! (author)2011-06-25

I tried to make the cookies, but they came out as a bubbling, smooshed (and after they cooled, a flat) mess. What did I do wrong? I used foil on the cookie sheet, because our cookie sheet is old. Could that have affected it? Also for the wet ingredients, do we stir them or use a hand mixer? Any and all help is appreciated. I really wanted to make some of these cookies tonight.

author
cdiaz11 made it! (author)cdiaz112011-09-19

Okay So like you use a hand mixer(electric Mixer) to mix the wet ingredients....if you are strong enough u can possibly do it by hand by i suggest using the mixer

author
tbrake made it! (author)tbrake2011-08-20

the last time that happened to mei just added a tiny bit more flour(1/3 of a cup)usually that works. humidity and temperature have alot to do with how much flour will work in any given recipe...hope this might help

author
fungus amungus made it! (author)fungus amungus2011-06-25

The wet ingredients are blended, so a hand mixer is great there. I just use a wooden spoon to stir in the dry ingredients. As for the bubbling mess and the flatness, maybe the oven is too hot. Is it at 350?

author
Daniel Heinrich made it! (author)2011-08-18

Really looks delicious :-)

Now I want to try it out for myself, but there actually are two questions remaining:

1) Which kind of butter did you use? (Churned, sweet, cultured, light, ...)
2) Which kind of oven was used? (Gas, convection, upper/lower heat, ...)

Well - any help is appreciated ;-)

Daniel

PS: Thanks for this nice recipe :-D

author
fungus amungus made it! (author)fungus amungus2011-08-20

Unsalted butter. Nothing fancy.

I cook in a gas oven. Typically, I place the tray towards the top.

Good luck!

author
sandymulberry made it! (author)2011-05-18

I just finished baking these, super delicious!

author
TerminalDragon made it! (author)2011-04-14

How do you dish ot a cup of peanut butter? This may sound incredibly dumb but isn't it difficult to be accurate with peanut butter that sticks and clumps if you get my drift?

author
pantanga34 made it! (author)pantanga342011-04-14

If you have a 2 cup measuring cup you fill it with 1 cup of water then put in peanut butter until the water gets to 2 cups. Then you have 1 cup water and 1 cup peanut butter so just drain the water and you're good to go.

author
TerminalDragon made it! (author)TerminalDragon2011-04-15

Thank you very much :) Now I can go make these, YAY!

author
Polarize made it! (author)2011-04-13

Great cookies :) 5/5

author
Nelyan made it! (author)2011-03-08

By the way, is that (finger)pose unintended? :)

author
happyjo made it! (author)2011-03-05

This is an awesome ible! These cookies will make for the perfect b'day gift!

author
Nelyan made it! (author)2011-02-25

What a great excuse for me to finally go and buy some peanutbutter! I always visited those of my friends who had imported real american peanutbutter when I was a kid, yummy! But for some strange reason, I've never bought it myself.
Thank you, this recipe made me make a new item on my tomorrow's grocerylist: peanut butter!

author
MariahWeezy123 made it! (author)2011-02-01

I love Peanut Butter!

author
CarmenCotelo made it! (author)2010-11-18

These are the first cookies I have ever made and they came out great. Thank you!

author
yaman.cool63 made it! (author)2010-09-11

oh man. Dough tastes so good. Cookies are in the oven now!!! So excited!!!

author
FlutterTree made it! (author)2010-08-27

My oven temperature went too high and the house filled up with smoke!!

author
Brndla made it! (author)2010-08-21

It would have been nice to see the inclusion of chocolate chips in the ingredients since the recipe is titled "Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies".....just an observation. Thanks

author
FlutterTree made it! (author)2010-08-19

They were all gone in 2 days... OMGSOFREAKINDELICIOUS!!!

author
ariella617 made it! (author)2010-04-11

I've been using this cookie recipe for so long that it's favorited on my computer! They're so delicious and the recipe calls for very few ingredients. I LOVE these cookies!! Thank you so much for sharing this recipe! <3

author
schicklet made it! (author)2009-09-17

These chocolate chip peanut butter cookies are delicious, but mine flattened out like too much. Can you tell me why????

author
never1before made it! (author)never1before2010-04-08

My guess would be that your oven was lying to you and that the temp was too low when you put the cookies in to bake.  If the temp isn't high enough for a crust to set on the outside before the rising action of the baking powder/soda or yeast, (if making bread), is completed, then you will have bottomed-out baked goods.

author
buddybarclay made it! (author)2010-03-23

you should try mixing the chocolate chips into the flour etc before adding it to the 'wet' ingredients
this cuts down on a bit of extra mixing as well you end up with fewer stray chips at the end of portioning them

author
b1russell made it! (author)2010-03-12

OK, these are, indeed, awesomely delicious.  But - there's always a but with me - I'm still looking for the PERFECT cookie recipe, which - IMHO - would be Peanut Butter-Chocolate Chip- Oatmeal Cookies.  I've found a pretty good peanut butter-oatmeal cookie, and I suppose I could just dump in some chips, but - if you happen to be in an inventing mood - you could probably develop the PERFECT recipe..  Right?!?

author
danlab made it! (author)2010-03-04

Mine aren't quite as pretty as your's are but they are still delicious. I didn't use insulated baking pan but I just used normal ones with silicone www.silpat.com/ baking sheets.

author
cx420ns made it! (author)2010-01-30

they would have been awesome, if my oven didn't suck balls.
everything i bake comes out with the bottom burnt.
of course now -after- i'm all out of ingredients i know what the problem is >.<
stupid element comes on too much.

author
d4v1d2r made it! (author)2010-01-13

DDDelicious cookies! very nice and easy way to do them too!
Thanks!

author
Yerboogieman made it! (author)2010-01-05

You forgot to include chocolate chips in the ingredients.

author
Cr4zy_Dud3_0n_F1r3 made it! (author)2009-12-21

5/5 Stars, amazing (I found about 1 cup to be half of the bag of chocolate chips).

author
louieaw made it! (author)2009-11-19

 I just made these DELICIOUS cookies. He isn't kidding when he says 12 minutes... I overcooked one batch. 

author
raaj606 made it! (author)2009-07-23

looks good, can't wait to make em before I do... why is sugar in wet ingredients?

author
humrattle made it! (author)humrattle2009-08-21

Well, brown sugar is a quasi dry ingredient. It does have some moisture in it... a very small bit of molasses I believe.

author
Punkguyta made it! (author)Punkguyta2009-09-29

I would consider sugar to be a dry ingredient if you ask me. A wet ingredient such as milk or water, pours when you lift it up. Something particulate such as sand or SUGAR for example, most people consider that pouring when they pour sand out of a container, as it has the same "flowing movement" that a liquid would have. However, because sugar and sand, alike, are actually constructed from tiny particles of solid sugar blocks, or sand how it's actually fine pieces of particulate glass, it is actually falling from the container as individual objects at a microscopic level when you pour sand or sugar from a container, where as with a liquid there is actual molecular bonding occurring and when you move the liquid, that is what causes a liquid (water for example) to slosh around when you shake it, because the bonds those molecules have, push and pull the surrounds molecules to/away from each other, where-as a "dry ingredient" such as sugar, does not have that. That's my lesson for today.

author
w1l50n1404 made it! (author)2009-08-31

I love your cookie so much! Yesterday, I baked them with my grandma and today I share it to my friends, they liked it! And I try making your cookie with raisins instead of chocolate chip and it tastes much delicious!

author
Artekus made it! (author)2009-08-18

These look great, I can't wait to try them! The trouble is that I'm British and hence really don't have a clue about the American cups system (although I do possess some. odd that) When you pack the sugar into the cup, is it about cramming as much sugar as you can possibly possibly fit in the cup, or more a whimsical prodding motion with the sugar spoon? I just don't want to end up with too much or (gasp) too little sugar.... Thanks very much

author
fungus amungus made it! (author)fungus amungus2009-08-18

Generally, I firmly pack the brown sugar in. It's about making sure there are no air pockets. No need to jump up and down on it though.

According to this site, 1 cup is 200g.

author
Artekus made it! (author)Artekus2009-08-19

Thanks very much and thanks too for the linky. I'll definitely be using it :)

author
lawizeg made it! (author)2008-06-23

WOAH! Just made for the second time. Delicious w/ withe choco-chips...yum!

author
fungus amungus made it! (author)fungus amungus2008-06-23

Nice! I have second recipe I've been slacking on putting up. The next time I make it I'll post about them. I like the new ones even better.

author
lawizeg made it! (author)lawizeg2008-06-27

Is there a place where we can reccommend contests?? cause i think we should have a sammich contest. mmm.

author
elecrulez made it! (author)elecrulez2009-07-02

a sandwich contest would be very good, or toast toppings :p

author
lawizeg made it! (author)lawizeg2008-06-27

Another question. can we enter instructables made before the date a contest begins into that contest?

author
lawizeg made it! (author)lawizeg2008-06-25

I can't really fathom a better cookie....

author
Rfinley01 made it! (author)2009-05-02

Just finished making and devouring these cookies. They are DELICIOUS! I'm going to be making these cookies a lot!

author
zoneykid made it! (author)2009-02-21

Hmm maybe someone can help me, i use an entire cup of honey instead of brown sugar and some extra flour but my cookies keep coming out more breadlike than like actual cookies...

author
chipman made it! (author)chipman2009-04-29

One of the problems with using larger doses of honey or molasses is that you are adding extra liquid to the recipes, which creates steam in the heated dough. This will not let the sugar and butter caramelize properly to create a crisp structure in the cookie. Adding extra flour does not help.

author
chipman made it! (author)chipman2009-04-29

addendum; I went and checked one of my professional cooking resources and... Molasses (honey) 1cup = 3/4 cup sugar plus 1/4 cup of liquid ( so reduce other liquids such as milk or water accordingly). Just to let you know.

author
krunal800 made it! (author)2009-01-28

hey great instructable...i made these but left out the chocolate chips......they came out pretty good but a tad too sweet......apart from that they were perfect!

About This Instructable

173,068views

341favorites

License:

Bio: I like to make things for the internets. I also sell a pretty cool calendar at supamoto.co. You'll like it.
More by fungus amungus:3D Printed US Population MapLight Painting With an IPhoneSuper Bright RGB LED Bike Wheels
Add instructable to: