DIY It's-Its

Introduction: DIY It's-Its

About: I live for adventure, community service, and the outdoors, and occasionally impersonate dinosaurs. I thoroughly enjoy baking at odd hours of the night, most especially without a recipe or the proper ingredien…

Make your own customized version of this classic frozen treat. We used oatmeal cookies and mint chocolate chip ice cream, but any combo can be delicious.

Step 1: Ingredients

You will need:
-1 dozen of your favorite cookie, relatively equally sized
-1 quart of your favorite ice cream (ideally complimentary to your cookie flavor)
-12oz chocolate chips or other melting chocolate
-2Tbsp butter
-a baking sheet that fits in your freezer

Makes six sandwiches

Note: I like the oatmeal cookie recipe that comes on the back of the carton of Quaker oats.

Step 2: Sandwiches

Remove ice cream from freezer to soften for a few minutes. Choose pairs of cookies that match sizes as well as possible. Spread softened ice cream on one cookie of each pair and squish together to make sandwiches, flat sides together. Place completed sandwiches on a baking sheet in your freezer and let chill for 1 hour.

Step 3: Chocolate!

Everybody likes chocolate. Well at least everybody should. So pretty much any dessert will be made better by being covered in chocolate.

Melt chocolate chips and butter in a pan on the stove, being careful to stir often to avoid burning he chocolate. If it gets too clumpy or grainy try adding a bit more butter.

Dip your frozen sandwiches in chocolate as quickly as possible to prevent melting the ice cream. You can try using a spoon for this but we had more success dipping by hand. Try to cover both sides and the ice cream edge with chocolate, using your fingers to smear across exposed areas as necessary.

Place chocolate-covered sandwiches on a baking sheet covered with wax paper and replace in freezer.

Step 4: Share and Enjoy

If you are superhuman you might be able to eat an entire sandwich by yourself, but if not you'll need to find some friends with whom to share. And fast if you're going to need to get back all that freezer space you've been taking up with your it's-its.

Frozen Treats Contest

Participated in the
Frozen Treats Contest

Be the First to Share


    • For the Home Contest

      For the Home Contest
    • Big and Small Contest

      Big and Small Contest
    • Game Design: Student Design Challenge

      Game Design: Student Design Challenge



    8 years ago on Introduction

    OMG, I need to make these. I grew up in Northern CA eating them, and I seriously almost paid like $30 to get a box shipped to me when I lived in Boston - I never even thought to make them when I was there! haha


    8 years ago on Introduction

    You've done a great service to humanity. Perhaps not my health, but to humanity nonetheless :)