Large DIY Vibratory Tumbler

9,859

96

15

Introduction: Large DIY Vibratory Tumbler

This instructable is a guide on how to design a vibratory tumbler. I couldn´t find a lot of information on how to build one, so I experimented and here are my findings that hopefully help you. This is somewhat of a advanced build, so I keep this simple and only show the important details.

Step 1: The Design

There are two types of tumblers, rotarry like a barrel filled with stones and vibratory which is more like a bathtub. They come in any size. I needed one for 1.2m long parts, so I made mine 130cm long. Aparently vibratory tumblers are more efficient than rotaty tumblers. The oder advantage is that you can see the parts as they are spinning and you can easily remove them. I was thinking about using a barrel first, but baralles are not long enough and getting the parts out would have been very difficult. So I went with the tub design.

Where to place the Motor?

Most industrial machines have two motors on either end of the tub. That makes a lot of sense to me, but the space in my workshop is limited so I wanted to keep it as compact as possible. Two motors are also more expensive than one and I belive that the industrial machines get custom made motors. Not standard industrial motors as I have used. Thats why I decided to mount the motor on the frame and independently from the tub. Otherwise I was affraird it would shake itself to bits.

Where to place the weight?

Somewhere in the middle! Not sure if underneath the tub or at the side is better. But it needs to be in the middle.

Step 2: Make the Machine Frame

What material to use?
I work with aluminium profiles a lot and accumulated a selection of scraps over the years. These are all parts with blemishes or holes, so I cannot use them for customers anymore. So I didn´t have to buy material and I got rid of scraps. Win win. Ideally you should use steel. It would be easier to weld and the slots in this case don´t add any value to the machine. You could also rivet the frame together instead of welding it. Using Aluminium has the advantage that it is easier to move around the workshop.

How to connect aluminium extrusions?

There are a lot of options. Check out my other instructable if you need ideas. https://www.instructables.com/id/Bandsaw-Stand-Ou...

How big should I make the frame?

I made mine 150cm long. So the tub has 10cm space to either side.

Step 3: Making the Tub

I didn´t make this. My sheetmetal supplier owed me one, so he made it for free. Its 4mm mild steel. Everything was bend and only the front and the end were welded on. I wasn´t sure if I could weld it watertight on my own, so that was one unknown out of the equation.

Its important that the tub is super ridgid. If I could do this again, I would add more braces on the outside. Maybe even a complete square pattern out of ribs. That way all the force from the vibrations will go into the media and not into the steel tub that flexes. In the video you sometimes see me use a clamp across the opening of the tub. That is there to keep the front side from flexing.

Step 4: Motor and Electronics

What Motor to chose?
I had a rough idea on how much power I would need, but no clue as to what speed would be right. So I went with 2.2kW which is somewhat of a standard size in Germany and then selected 1440RPM which is the median model. There was also 700RPM and 3000RPM available. I figured that I can change this with some pulleys if it was wrong. The VFD of course adjusts the speed, so I was only focusing on the power.

What VFD?

The VFD makes it possible to adjust the motor speed. Otherwise it would just run on full speed like a table saw does. On cordless drills you can change the speed by altering the voltage. That only works at low voltages and DC power. With 230V, you need a VFD. In brushless cordless drills there is a miniature version of a VFD. It kinda manipulates and changes the power as it comes in in such a way that the motor achieves a certain speed. Complicated stuff and I am no expert. However if you want variable speed, you need a VFD. Variable speed is important to get the right vibrations.

My VFD is from Yaskawa. It was on sale and it is made in Japan. So I can be confident that it will work great. I cannot reccomend cheap knockoff VFDs at all!

How to wire it up?
If you are buying from a proper motor dealer, just ask them for advice. I learned that shielded motor cables are important for VFDs. They can eliminate issues, but you could be lucky without one.




Step 5: Power Transmission

Overall design:

The motor is connected to a sliding universal joint. That way the tub can move independently from the tub. Without this setup, this machine would not run at all. You could of course mount the motor directly to the tub, but then it might shake itself to bits, or the shaft of the motor could break. These motors are not designed to have large radial forces on their shafts. If they are running a table saw or similar, the radial forces are tiny compared to when they are flying around a huge unbalanced weight.


Parts to use:

The main goal here is to make everything beefy. My shafts are all 25mm thick and I wouldn´t go smaller than this.
The U-Joint is an awesome piece of machinery and extremly high quality. If you cannot find one as cheap as this, you can try sourcing one from farming equipment or from a car. They have a similar part at driven front wheels.
For the pulleys I used taper locks. Amazing stuff. No need for keyways and super easy to assemble and tighten.
I used 10mm V-Belts which is one of the smallest sizes. I think its the same as on any drill press. They work fine.

Counterweight:
I used whatever I had lying around. I ended up with 1.5kg. Safety is key, so make sure it is on there properly. In terms of coupling the mass to the shaft, I found that it will always spin with the shaft. You don´t need to clamp it on tightly like a pulley or gear. A zip tie would probably add enough clamping force to make it spin. Obviously you want some steel to hold it on. A zip tie allone would snap, but it is enough clamping force to keep it going. I kept it so simple and crude because I was doing trial and error. Now that I know how heavy it needs to be at 50Hz, I can make a proper weight that looks nicer.

Step 6: Add a Drain.

Ultimately you are going to need a drain and a water hookup. The tumbling generates dust and it needs to be washed away. So add a drain at the bottom and also a fresh water supply. Check with your local muncipality on how to dispose the water.

Step 7: Tumbling Media

There is a wide array on media out there. I recommend calling a supplier and asking for advice.

I chose a medium grit so it is rough enough to quickly remove a burr, but also not as aggressive to keep a smooth finish. This is plastic media which is a little bit more leightweight than ceramic media. That reduces the swinging mass on the tumbler so the forces on the shafts and bearings don´t have to be as great.

This stuff is expensive. I payed €1200,- for 150kg of media. But I know it will last a long time and just a few loads will pay for this machine. Sending my pallets to a tumbling company and back would cost €200 alone plus the work of course.

Be the First to Share

    Recommendations

    • Make it Fly Challenge

      Make it Fly Challenge
    • Summer Fun: Student Design Challenge

      Summer Fun: Student Design Challenge
    • First Time Author Contest

      First Time Author Contest

    15 Comments

    0
    KellyCraig
    KellyCraig

    10 months ago on Step 7

    Would love to see a before and after photo of what you tumbled with this.

    Nice job. Nice in fact and deed.

    0
    Max Maker
    Max Maker

    Reply 10 months ago

    You can see it at the end. Last minute or so.

    0
    KellyCraig
    KellyCraig

    Reply 10 months ago

    Must have been a cup of coffee short of awake when I went through your ible (don't know how I missed that video).

    Thanks.

    After watching it, your build is all the more impressive.

    It'd be fun to see what finer media would do with something. Perhaps even sand, though one would want to control the silica dust issue with such things.

    In time, I assume the media would take a toll on the container, just as cleaning metal parts in a sonic cleaner does.

    Since you vibrate mechanically, it would seem even using silicone caulk to hold metal panels over the surfaces of the tub may not pose too much of a dampening problem.

    0
    Max Maker
    Max Maker

    Reply 8 months ago

    Thanks for watching! I am happy with the current result in terms of the suface quality. However, sometimes large parts rub against the container or something like that and create bad spots. So I plan soon to empty out the entire drum, wash it and then to coat it with epoxy paint. Once that has cured, I will glue on some 3mm rubber matts with contact cement. That way the walls are soft, and the steel cannot rust anymore and of course the epoxy is also save from abbrasions.

    0
    KellyCraig
    KellyCraig

    Reply 7 months ago

    Good stuff. If the 3-M goes too quick, look at horse mats. They're so thick and heavy they wouldn't need glue.

    0
    seamster
    seamster

    10 months ago

    Man, what a fun project. I love seeing stuff like this. Ugly yet beautiful at the same time! Can't argue with the results. Great to see, very well done :D

    0
    Max Maker
    Max Maker

    Reply 8 months ago

    Thank you!

    0
    Max Maker
    Max Maker

    Reply 10 months ago

    Thank you for your kind words!

    0
    Max Maker
    Max Maker

    Reply 10 months ago

    Thanks! Glad that you enjoyed it.

    0
    Norm1958
    Norm1958

    10 months ago

    Thank you for the inspiration.

    0
    Max Maker
    Max Maker

    Reply 8 months ago

    Thanks for watching!

    0
    Max Maker
    Max Maker

    Reply 10 months ago

    Thank you for watching!

    0
    jeanniel1
    jeanniel1

    10 months ago

    Impressive build from scratch and from thought to reality. I found it amusing to see the trampoline springs start with four of them and end up with (18) of them! That certainly says something about the vibrations. As for the welding - yeah, aluminum welding isn't as easy as steel. Plus, to make it more "beautiful" you can grind down and smooth the rough joins.

    Super neat project here!

    0
    Max Maker
    Max Maker

    Reply 8 months ago

    Thanks! Yes I had no idea about the springs. Ordering special springs in the right size would have been impossible. The trampoline springs were very versatile in that way. Had I ordered some, I would definitley had bought the wrong kind.

    0
    Max Maker
    Max Maker

    10 months ago

    Yes, I worry a little bit about the tub. Commercial tubs have a 10mm 2k PU coating which I cannot really do at home. On ther other hand, the tub is very imple and should it wear through it would be a cheap part to replace. What I could do right now would be PE sheets that I could rivet against the hull. That should also decrease the friction inside.

    If you want to find out more about media its best to contact a supplier. They have a ton of different materials to choose. A finer grit can get you polished surfaces, but that also means that they don´t remove burrs.