Tell us about yourself!
You are right, electrolytic rust removal is far-and-away better. You'll often be able to recover even etchings, makers marks, etc. that the acid bath will have destroyed. A concern, particularly for tools that flex (like hand saws) is hydrogen embrittlement. This, however, can be counteracted by baking the tool at 350-400 degrees for four hours or so immediately after being removed from the electrolytic tank. I'd recommend sodium carbonate (washing soda) instead of bicarbonate.
Fantastic job! Thank you!
200kW AC Motor Controller for Electric Car