Introduction: Easy Overnight English Muffin Recipe
This dough is best prepared the night before so that you can let it proof in the fridge overnight, and then cook it any time the next morning.
Be sure to check out even more glutenous goodness in my Bread Class!
For this dough, you have two options. You can make the same baguette dough as outlined in this Instructable, yielding a chewy distinctly sourdough open-nook-and-cranny-delicious muffin, and skip right ahead to the forming section below, OR you can try to make an enriched English muffin.
Enriched doughs are any doughs that are mixed with ingredients beyond flour, water, yeast, and salt. Enriching a dough with foods like fatty oils , milk, and sugars affect the way gluten bonds are formed. These ingredients hinder the dough's ability to create long bonds that stretch into large open bubbles during the baking process, yielding a tighter softer crumb, but also a more savory flavor and longer shelf stability.
So, the choice is yours! If you loved the way that last lesson's baguette dough baked and desire a sour chewy English muffin, skip to below and see instructions on how to form the dough once bulk fermentation has completed. If you are ready to try your hand at working with another dough enriched with fat, sugar, and milk, you have chosen wisely and your taste buds are already thanking you.
Step 1: Tools & Ingredients
Here are the tools and ingredients required to follow along with this lesson.
- Mixing bowl
- Medium baking sheet
- Kitchen towel or oven bag
- Cast iron skillet or griddle, but a thick bottomed skillet could work as well
- 200 grams all-purpose flour
- 300 grams bread flour
- 350 grams water, 125-135 degrees
- one packet of instant yeast
- 15 grams powder milk
- 12-15 grams salt
- 20 grams, or 2 and a half tablespoons sugar
- 2 tablespoons shortening
You will also need to mix up a 50/50 all purpose flour and rice flour mix for dusting. Some recipes call for cornmeal, but the gritty meal has a tendency to burn in the skillet and scorch the muffins.
Step 2: Bulk Mix
The bulk mix for this dough is very straight forward. Perfect to whip up after dinner, let it proof while watching a movie, then punch down and form before bed, letting the shaped rise happen in the fridge.
Combine the all purpose flour, white bread flour, and intant yeast into one large mixing bowl. Stir with a whisk and create a well in the middle for liquids.
In a separate saucepan, measure out 350 grams of water and set aside. In small cup or dish, weigh out the dry milk, sugar, salt, and shortening.
Whisk the ingredients in the saucepan together until the dry ingredients have completely dissolved in the water. Heat the mixture on the stove until it reaches between 120-130.
Pour the heated mixture into the well in the center of the bowl of dry ingredients. Using a dough whisk or a wooden spoon to get these ingredients incorporated is recommended.
This is a high hydration dough, meaning it is super sticky to work with until the yeast has had time to go to work. Once the ingredients are fully incorporated and pulling away from the side of the bowl, set aside for 5 to 10 minutes.
Step 3: Knead and Bulk Ferment
Giving the dough a minute to rest before kneading alleviates some of the knead time, and gives the warm water a few extra minutes to activate the yeast and hydrate the dry ingredients. Using a bowl scraper, separate the dough from the bowl and turn it out onto a lightly floured surface.
Flour your countertop, and knead the dough for about 5 to 10 minutes. Work the dough until it is smooth across the surface and feels evenly hydrated, separating easily from your fingers. Work in a little extra flour during kneading, but no more than three or four tablespoons.
Clean out the bowl you mixed the dough in, and film it with a layer of spray oil. Transfer the dough back into the bowl, and spritz the top of the dough as well before covering it with a towel or plastic wrap, allowing the dough bulk ferment.
This dough doubles quickly because the yeast has additional sugar to snack on during this fermentation and the high temperature of the liquid we added. Check your dough after 30 minutes, but depending on how cool the dough became during kneading it can take up to an hour to double.
Step 4: Turn Out Dough
Place a kitchen towel on a baking sheet. Dust the towel until it is covered in thin layer of rice flour. Then dust again with a 50:50 mixture of rice flour to all purpose flour. Flouring the towel really well ensures that these sticky muffins won't get stuck to the towel.
After bulk fermentation turn out the dough onto the well-floured towel and allow to relax for 10 minutes.
Dust the top of the dough with the rice flour and all-purpose flour mixture, then press the dough from the middle outward until you have filled the pan with a half inch thick dough. Don't worry if you don't reach the edges of your pan, it's more important to have a consistent thickness across the dough.
Cover the dough with plastic wrap or place in an oven bag before letting the dough rest in the fridge overnight.
Step 5: Cutting and Cooking
Remove your dough from the fridge and observe how puffed it has become overnight!
This dough is best cooked in a cast iron pan or griddle. Spray oil works great, but if you want a richer crust flavor, you can cook the muffins in ghee. Ghee can take a minute to make but is amazing to use for cooking. Ghee also seems to be commercially available almost everywhere now, so check your nearest supermarket.
Heat the skillet over medium to low heat for at least 5 minutes before cooking. I am using the skillet half of the combination cooker.
Using a four inch round cookie cutter, cut rounds from the dough when you are ready to place them in the pan. If you don't want round English muffins, you can just slice the dough slab into rectangles with a sharp knife or a pizza cutter.
You should be able to squeeze six large muffins out of this initial cut. Gently remove the extra dough, cutting with a sharp paring knife if it sticks. Re-knead the removed dough with about a tablespoon of water, and set aside for the moment.
Using a spatula, transfer your muffins 3 at a time into the skillet at medium-low heat. Don't worry if they begin to puff unevenly in the pan, with the top expanding to be larger than bottom. When the underside is golden brown, flip the muffins.
Cook the second side other side of the muffins until gold brown, pressing them slightly into the pan after being flipped. This should take about 6-8 minutes per side.
Place the muffins onto a cooling rack and allow them to cool for 5 to 10 minutes before splitting and toasting.
While you are waiting for your muffin rounds to cook, re-flour your kitchen towel slightly and press the dough you hydrated and kneaded into the pan. Allow to rest for 10 minutes, or until visibly relaxed, before cutting with a smaller dough cutter, or simply cutting into fourths and cooking in the pan.
Step 6: Serving and Storing
Before serving, slice the muffin in half and toast face down in a dry skillet.
Look at all those nooks and crannies! Perfect for melting butter in. Or cheese.
My favorite thing to make in these muffins is an egg sandwich. A creamy salty cheese like brie, allowed to get melted by a fried egg, topped with prosciutto and mustard is a savory breakfast dream.
If you'd like to make a sourdough version of this muffin, try using the dough recipe from this baguette Instructable.
Interested in more easy bread recipes? Check out this dough that never ever doubles in size, because well, it shouldn't. Flatbread!
5 years ago
I made these and they were good except I didn't get the "nooks and crannies." I'm a beginner so maybe I did something wrong. I did follow the recipe as best as I could. Does anyone know why I didn't get the "bubbles?" Thanks!
5 years ago
These look sooooo good! I moved to Europe some years ago, and english muffins are definitely something I miss a lot (along with breakfast sausage and a good donut!) Yeah - all the healthy stuff ;) But I'm curious - will alternatives to powdered milk and dry yeast give just a good results (thought I'd ask before trying)? Powdered milk is impossible to find here, and dry yeast is also a needle in a hay stack. Any thoughts? Otherwise...I'll just have to experiment myself :) Thanks for a great instructable!
Reply 5 years ago
You absolutely need the yeast, it is a leavening agent in the bread and is what creates all the air pockets in the dough.
Sometimes I use cashew milk or almond milk instead of dry powdered milk and water, and I just add a little extra flour to make up for the loss of dry ingredients.
5 years ago
Now how about a recipe for BIALYS? For the uninitiated, a bialy is a bagel that has died and gone to heaven, but even Kossars on Grand Street in Manhattan doesn't make good ones anymore. And the ones made by Bell's of Brooklyn qualify (like their bagels) as a kind of culinary anti-semitism.
5 years ago
These look pretty good. I recommend fork-splitting above knife-slicing, however. Will they be what I'm after, which is something close as possible to the Thomas' English Muffins sold at retail? Those re the only ones worth eating. The supposed replicants include Vernont Baking (fair), Pepperidge Farm (awful) Holsum (worse) among others.