The Lost Art of the Conic Section Compass

6,877

58

21

Introduction: The Lost Art of the Conic Section Compass

If you are reading this then the title was catching enough :)

So what's this instructable about? It will show you how to 3D print a Conic Section Compass at home. In mathematics, a conic section (or simply conic) is a curve obtained as the intersection of the surface of a cone with a plane. The three types of conic section are the hyperbola, the parabola, and the ellipse; the circle is a special case of the ellipse. No continuous arc of a conic can be constructed with straightedge and regular compass.

The Conic Section Compass (also known as Perfect Compass) is not a novelty: in the second half of the 10th century, the Arabic scholar al-Sijzi wrote a treatise on this new instrument. At the end of the Middle-Age, this instrument disappears and comes back at the Renaissance as a drawing tool. A very nice version by Leonardo Da Vinci can be seen in the Codex Atlanticus.

This device can give a good entry point for an activity that helps the students to understand the way a mathematical theory is elaborated. In secondary school, the conics are often studied only from a cartesian point of view. For students, and for teachers too, the work on the perfect compass restores the link between real world and mathematics models.

Supplies:

    The bill of material is quite short:

    • 3D model. Both STL and STEP files are included should you need to make any modification.
    • soft pencil (does mine look familiar? :)
    • M5x25 screw, washer and nut

    Teacher Notes

    Teachers! Did you use this instructable in your classroom?
    Add a Teacher Note to share how you incorporated it into your lesson.

    Step 1: Build It

    Building this device will require not more than 5 minutes (excluding the 3D printing of course):

    • assemble shaft and base, align them and tighten the M5 screw. To avoid damaging the 3D printed parts do not apply too much torque, but just enough to block the joint.
    • mount the pencil holder. it's a press-fit connection and it should be able to rotate easily around the shaft.
    • glue the base on a flat surface.
    • insert the pencil. It should slide easily guided by its own weight.
    • position a piece of paper in front of the compass and fix it with scotch tape. I cut a slot in mine to gain some more drawing surface.

    You are ready to go!

    Step 2: Use It!

    A Conic Section Compass can continuosly trace conic sections exploiting the very definition of it. In this particular build the pencil lays on the surface of a 30 degrees cone (but it could be any other angle) and can freely slide in the pencil holder: in this way it will always be in contact with the intersection surface (the paper sheet). Rotating the pencil holder around the cone axis and being careful to maintain the contact between pencil and paper we will be able to trace different conic sections:

    1. circle: where the cone axis is perpendicular to the intersecting surface
    2. ellipse: where the cone axis is between the perpendicular position and the position where the generatrix is parallel to the intersecting surface
    3. parabola: when the cone generatrix is parallel to the intersecting surface
    4. hyperbola: where the cone axis is between the position where the generatrix is parallel to the intersecting surface and the position where the cone axis is parallel to the intersecting surface

    The trace left by the pencil is very light but you can easily retrace it by hand to make it clearer.

    This is it, a very short instructable on a very important topic: I anyway hope this is enough to shed some light on the fascinating world of the conics.

    If you enjoyed it please vote for me in the contest! :)

    Made with Math Contest

    Second Prize in the
    Made with Math Contest

    Be the First to Share

      Recommendations

      • Magnets Challenge

        Magnets Challenge
      • Snow Challenge

        Snow Challenge
      • Wearables Contest

        Wearables Contest

      21 Discussions

      1
      jeanniel1
      jeanniel1

      2 months ago

      This is awesome! I have friends who have kids asking about MORE Math problems and projects! Will share this with them. Voted for this!

      0
      hombremagnetico
      hombremagnetico

      Reply 2 months ago

      Thanks jeanniel1! :)

      1
      kymyst
      kymyst

      2 months ago

      Because the apex angle of the cone is not adjustable, it can only draw a limited range of conics. Also, why would you need to glue the base to the drawing board ?

      0
      hombremagnetico
      hombremagnetico

      Reply 2 months ago

      Hi kymyst, yes I chose a 30 degrees angle at the apex and I didn't implement any adjustment mechanism to keep the whole thing as simple as possible: it's meant to be just a demonstrator. Gluing it to the board is not mandatory but it helps a lot while tracing the curves.

      0
      kymyst
      kymyst

      Reply 2 months ago

      Here is one I made from odds and ends with an adjustable apex angle. Of course it is still limited in the range of conics which can be drawn because of the base diameter and pencil length.

      IMG_0085.jpg
      2
      AlexanderS290
      AlexanderS290

      2 months ago

      some video would have been quite fine - and would have obsoleted so many questions.
      maybe you (or someone else) can upload one to show the action. ;-)

      0
      hombremagnetico
      hombremagnetico

      Reply 2 months ago

      That's a good idea!

      0
      M.J2
      M.J2

      Reply 2 months ago

      Yes a video would be great.
      I simply cannot get my feeble mind around exactly what this does.

      1
      Ralphxyz
      Ralphxyz

      2 months ago

      I guess I'll have to make one, if I ever get my 3D printer working again.
      I cannot see how you get anything but a circle.
      It would be nice to see the holder in the middle of the paper drawing the shape. Oh well.

      1
      AlexanderS290
      AlexanderS290

      Reply 2 months ago

      the pen is going along the surface of a cone.
      the trick is that the angular axis is fixed during a certain setup
      whilst the pen is moving along this axis using the small joint in the main stick for its rotation.

      0
      hombremagnetico
      hombremagnetico

      Reply 2 months ago

      Hi Ralphxyz, I agree, it is counterintuitive. It's easier to build one and try it! Let me know how it goes! :)

      1
      AlexanderS290
      AlexanderS290

      2 months ago

      okay - its seems to be a fine trick to bring cone intersection cuts onto a paper.
      the variable length (or its slide by the shaft) of the pencil works like the surface of a cone.
      thus all realistic rules for shapes that would apply to cone intersections will be able to end up on the paper.

      0
      hombremagnetico
      hombremagnetico

      Reply 2 months ago

      Thanks AlexanderS290!

      1
      foxpup
      foxpup

      2 months ago

      Wouldn't the shapes work like this?
      Position1: Circle
      Between Position1 and Position2: Elipse
      Position2: Parabola
      Beyond Position 2: Hyperbola

      0
      hombremagnetico
      hombremagnetico

      Reply 2 months ago

      Thanks foxpup! It's much clearer in this way. I'll update the text... :)

      1
      coastaleddy
      coastaleddy

      2 months ago

      Thank you. I didn't even know these existed. I'll have to make one when I have time.

      0
      hombremagnetico
      hombremagnetico

      Reply 2 months ago

      Thanks! Share it if you do! :)

      1
      RicardoC146
      RicardoC146

      2 months ago

      Excellent work! This compass is a marvel!

      1
      hombremagnetico
      hombremagnetico

      Reply 2 months ago

      Thanks! I tried to keep it as simple as possible...

      1
      ronanry
      ronanry

      2 months ago

      thank you ! just learned a thing today ! (didn't know those kind of equipment would exists)