Hi, The pen does in fact work, as long as you seal the open end of the ink in step 4.
After testing it out further, that does happen, but for me the ink lasts a while before stopping. Long enough that I didn't realize as I was testing out the pen before I posted.
DIY Oil and Water PenView Instructable »
Easy Recycled Braided Dog Toys
DIY Washi Tape Stickers (Great for Laptops!)View Instructable »
Easy Recycled Braided Dog ToysView Instructable »